|
|
|
Introduction |
|
Spirituality is one of four essential aspects of being human: biological,
psychological, social, and spiritual. Our wellness depends on the integrity of
each of these aspects and their balanced interrelationship. Spirituality,
therefore, is not a healing modality per se. Rather, it is an aspect of life
that, like the others, may be "dis-eased" and may therefore require healing. The
modalities for spiritual healing are the spiritual disciplines:
prayer/meditation, forgiveness, service, and religious practice (including such
religious healing practices as the "laying on" of hands), among others. Because
the four aspects of being are interdependent, weakness or illness in one
inevitably strains the others. If the ill organism is to regain its balance and
optimal functioning, the vitality of all four aspects must be addressed.
The manifestation of spirituality in people's lives has been described in
numerous ways: a belief in a power operating in the universe that is greater
than oneself (Post et al. 2000); an awareness of the purpose and meaning of life
(Gundersen 2000); a sense of interconnectedness with all living things; and the
development of personal, absolute values. Although spirituality is often
associated with religious practice, many believe that personal spirituality can
be developed outside of organized religion. Acts of compassion, altruism, and
the experience of inner peace are all characteristics of spirituality.
Many Americans are expressing increasing interest in the role of spirituality
in their health and health care. Some observers believe this may be due, in
part, to dissatisfaction with the impersonal nature of our medical system, and
to the realization that medical science does not have answers to all questions
about the maintenance of health and wellness (Gundersen 2000).
|
|
|
Historical Background |
|
In most healing traditions and through generations of healers in the early
beginnings of Western medicine, concerns of the body and spirit were
intertwined. With the advent of the mechanistic, technological approach to
health and healing that characterized the scientific revolution and the
Enlightenment, non-rational considerations were expunged from the medical system
(Gundersen 2000). Today, there seems to be a renewal of interest in exploring
how the spiritual dimension of existence impacts health.
Scientific surveys indicate that spirituality plays an important role in the
majority of patients' lives. Ninety-four percent of patients believe doctors
should ask the seriously ill about their religious beliefs (Ehman et al. 1999).
Sixty-four percent feel that physicians should pray with patients who request it
(Astin et al. 2000), and forty-five percent state that religion would influence
their medical decisions if they were seriously ill (Ehman et al. 1999).
Twenty-five percent of patients report that they use prayer as a healing therapy
for themselves (Koenig 2000). |
|
|
Terminology |
|
- Spirit is considered the essential nature of a
person.
- Spiritual healing involves
"the intentional influence of one or more persons upon another living system without utilizing known physical means of intervention"
(Astin et al. 2000).
- Spiritual awareness describes an awareness of that which is not
tangible or material, especially of the ultimate meaning and purpose of life.
There may be a heightened awareness of, and concern for, such matters during
times of illness or when facing death.
- Prayer may be defined as openness to or communication with the
transcendent, and may be practiced within or outside of an organized religious
context. Transcendence can be thought of loosely as the nonmaterial or
universal aspects of being that go beyond one's individual
existence.
- Intercessory prayer involves
"asking a higher power to intervene on behalf of [another] individual" in order
to benefit that person's well being (Astin et al. 2000). Intercessory prayer and
distance healing are frequently used interchangeably in medical
literature, although one distinction may be that distance healing refers to any
"dedicated act of mentation," not necessarily prayer in the classic sense of the
word (Astin et al. 2000; Sicher et al. 1998). In either intercessory prayer or
distance healing, the person performing the prayer or act of mentation
frequently does not know the person for whom they pray.
Mechanisms of Action
Spiritual disciplines potentially improve coping skills and social support;
foster feelings of optimism and hope; promote healthy behavior, such as
avoidance of tobacco and alcohol; and reduce feelings of depression and anxiety
(Gundersen 2000). Spiritual practices can induce the relaxation response and
allow people to participate in uplifting rituals (Matthews 2000). Thus, such
practices ameliorate stress responses involving neurological, endocrine, immune,
and cardiovascular function (Koenig 2000). The effects of spirituality seem to
be explained best by Mind-Body Medicine, now frequently referred to as
psychoneuroimmunology, which represents bi-directional communication between the
central nervous, neuroendocrine, and immune systems (Masek et al. 2000). Prayer
seems to confer an additional advantage: Those who engage in regular prayer are
more likely to avail themselves of available medical resources (Matthews
2000).
Clinical trials demonstrate that personal prayer has physiological effects on
the patient similar to those of meditation, including reduction of hypertension
(Koenig 2000). How intercessory prayer works is not clearly understood or easily
explained (Gundersen 2000). A possible theory involves the influence of the
belief system of the person engaging in spiritual activities, or for whom, in
the case of distance healing, others are praying (Krucoff 1999).
|
|
|
Clinical Evaluation |
|
Physicians who feel uncomfortable or unfamiliar with spirituality and prayer
should refer patients with spiritual issues to a member of the clergy, a
chaplain, pastoral counselor or other spiritual authority (Koenig 2000; Post et
al. 2000). Such religious professionals discuss spiritual beliefs and concerns
with patients, and, if appropriate, encourage patients to pray and then pray
along with them. Pastoral counselors often make available to their clients a
clinical psychological perspective as well as an array of spiritual resources.
Follow-up appointments are scheduled as needed. If a patient is without a
religious affiliation or prefers a practice outside of organized religion, there
are non-religious disciplines, such as tai chi and yoga, which for many
encompass spiritual qualities. Please see the monographs on those individual
modalities for more information. |
|
|
Clinical Applications |
|
Spiritual disciplines may be especially effective for drug and alcohol
addiction, since popular and successful programs, such as Alcoholics Anonymous,
incorporate a strong spiritual component and maintain a conviction that a
spiritual awakening is crucial to full recovery (Gundersen 2000).
Research on intercessory prayer for cardiac patients indicates that although
length of stay in a coronary care unit (CCU) was not affected, blinded
intercessory prayer did reduce morbidity of CCU patients as measured by the Mid
America Heart Institute-Cardiac Care Unit scoring system (MAHI-CCU). The
MAHI-CCU score includes factors such as the development of unstable angina,
pneumonia, hypotension, anemia, congestive heart failure, and arrhythmias; the
need for medication, Swan-Ganz catheterization, pacemakers, cardiac
defibrillators, and major surgery; and cardiac arrest. Also of note from this
same study is the fact that the CCU patients and those involved with their
medical care were unaware that lay intercessors, who did not know and never met
the patients, were praying for them (Harris et al. 1999).
Intercessory prayer has also been reported to reduce pain, fatigue,
tenderness, and swelling, and to improve grip strength and function for patients
with rheumatoid arthritis (Matthews 2000). Although such observations are
intriguing, methodological limitations of studies on intercessory prayer make it
difficult to draw definitive conclusions about clinical applications (Astin et
al. 2000).
Spiritual disciplines enhance the coping skills of people with chronic
illness by reducing uncertainty and promoting self-esteem. Religious practices
have shown some evidence-based success as an adjunct in treatment for specific
chronic conditions such as arthritis, cystic fibrosis, diabetes, chronic renal
failure, coronary artery disease, and spinal cord injury (Matthews 2000). These
practices may also be particularly suited for chronic disabilities that are
unresponsive to medical treatment, and for anxiety, depression, and
stress-related disorders (Koenig 2000). Religious affiliation specifically may
improve quality of life, as studies show that regular church attendance improves
health and increases longevity (Gundersen 2000). |
|
|
Risks, Side Effects, Adverse
Events |
|
The inclusion of spiritual considerations in health care is controversial and
raises a number of ethical questions (Post et al. 2000). Some physicians feel
that adverse effects may result if they are involved in areas outside of their
expertise. Others hold that physician advocacy of spiritual practices can be
inappropriate and intrusive and may induce guilt or harm, leading patients to
believe that ill health is a result of insufficient faith. There is also the
possibility that physicians could influence or be insensitive to a patient's
religious beliefs or lack thereof (Gundersen 2000). Finally, there is the risk
that people may substitute prayer for medical care, or that spiritual practices
could delay the receipt of medical treatment; in this regard, children with
parents whose religious beliefs conflict with conventional medical practices may
be at particular risk (Koenig 2000). |
|
|
Contraindications |
|
No specific contraindications to spiritual disciplines are known to be
reported in the literature to date. See section on Risks, Side Effects, Adverse
Events for additional details. |
|
|
Additional Clinical
Outcomes |
|
There is a need for more well-designed, controlled clinical trials that
exclude such confounding factors as psychological comorbidity and health
behaviors affected by religious practices (Gundersen 2000; Astin et al. 2000).
Future research also needs to focus more on spiritual practice beyond church
attendance and organized religious activity (Gundersen
2000). |
|
|
The Future |
|
More than 30 medical schools in the United States have incorporated spiritual
teachings into their curricula, with a focus on how to talk to patients about
their spiritual beliefs and needs (Gundersen 2000). However, as illustrated in
the section on Risks, Side Effects, Adverse Events, physicians remain divided
over what role they should play in assisting or guiding patients in spiritual
matters (Gundersen 2000; Post et al. 2000).
If physicians do inquire about or engage in spiritual and prayer-based forms
of healing, they should do so with an open, accepting, and sensitive attitude
that addresses all religious beliefs with dignity, respect, and integrity.
Spirituality and prayer may be a safe and cost-effective adjunct to medical
treatment (Matthews 2000). |
|
|
Training, Certification, and
Licensing
Requirements |
|
Priests, nuns, pastors, and rabbis receive training in pastoral care from
their respective institutions. In addition, certified chaplains and pastoral
counselors are extensively trained in the spiritual and emotional needs of ill,
disabled, or terminal patients (Koenig 2000). |
|
|
Resources |
|
For additional information regarding the discipline of pastoral counseling
specifically, contact the American Association of Pastoral Counselors in
Fairfax, Virginia at 703-385-6967 or on the web at www.aapc.org. To learn more
about the role of spirituality in health, including the latest research, contact
the National Institute for Healthcare Research in Rockville, Maryland at
301-984-7162 or on the web at www.nihr.org. |
|
|
References |
|
Astin JA, Harkness E, Ernst E. The efficacy of "distant healing": a
systematic review of randomized trials. Ann Intern Med.
2000;132(11):903-910.
Ehman JW, Ott BB, Short TH, Ciampa RC, Hansen-Flaschen J. Do patients want
physicians to inquire about their spiritual or religious beliefs if they become
gravely ill? Arch Intern Med. 1999;159(15):1803-1806.
Gundersen L. Faith and healing. Ann Intern Med.
2000;132(2):169-172.
Harris WS, Gowda M, Kolb JW, et al. A randomized, controlled trial of the
effects of remote, intercessory prayer on outcomes in patients admitted to the
coronary care unit. Arch Intern Med. 1999;159(19):2273-2278.
Krucoff MW. Mitchell W. Krucoff, MD: the MANTRA study project. Altern Ther
Health Med. 1999;5(3):75-82.
Koenig HG. Spiritual healing and prayer. In: Novey DW, ed. Clinician's
Complete Reference to Complementary and Alternative Medicine. St. Louis, Mo:
Mosby; 2000:130-140.
Masek K, Petrovicky P, Sevcik J, Zidek Z, Frankova D. Past, present and
future of psychoneuroimmunology. Toxicology. 2000;142(3):179-188.
Matthews DA. Prayer and spirituality. Rheum Dis Clin North Am.
2000;26(1):177-187.
Post SG, Puchalski CM, Larson DB. Physicians and patient spirituality:
professional boundaries, competency, and ethics. Ann Intern Med.
2000;132(7):578-583.
Sicher F, Targ E, Moore D II, Smith HS. A randomized double-blind study of
the effect of distant healing in a population with advanced AIDS. West J
Med.
1998;169(6):356-363. |
|
Copyright © 2000 Integrative Medicine
Communications This publication contains
information relating to general principles
of medical care that should not in any event be construed as specific
instructions for individual patients. The publisher does not accept any
responsibility for the accuracy of the information or the consequences arising
from the application, use, or misuse of any of the information contained herein,
including any injury and/or damage to any person or property as a matter of
product liability, negligence, or otherwise. No warranty, expressed or implied,
is made in regard to the contents of this material. No claims or endorsements
are made for any drugs or compounds currently marketed or in investigative use.
The reader is advised to check product information (including package inserts)
for changes and new information regarding dosage, precautions, warnings,
interactions, and contraindications before administering any drug, herb, or
supplement discussed herein. | |